The Substance (2024)

Rating: 4/5

Plot Summary

"The Substance," directed by Coralie Fargeat, is a 2024 body horror film that’s making quite a splash with its daring narrative and cheeky critique of society’s obsession with youth and beauty. Starring Demi Moore as Elisabeth Sparkle and Margaret Qualley as Sue, the film dives into the grotesque results of using a mysterious drug for that flawless look. This is one of those movies that’s likely to be divisive. With its cocktail of horror, satire, and social commentary, "The Substance" serves up a chilling yet thought-provoking take on the endless chase for eternal youth.

The plot of The Substance centers on Elisabeth Sparkle, a fading Hollywood star who, in a desperate bid to revive her career, turns to "The Substance"—a mysterious injection that creates a younger, idealized version of herself named Sue. But there’s a catch: Elisabeth and Sue must alternate their existence every seven days, with one living while the other is in stasis. As Sue takes over more, Elisabeth’s body starts to decay, leading to a horrifying battle for control of her identity. The film dives deep into themes of identity, self-perception, and the dark side of the beauty industry, critiquing the societal pressures that push people, especially women, to extreme lengths for perfection. Through its horror elements, The Substance really amplifies the psychological and physical toll of these demands, making a powerful statement about the destructive nature of vanity and obsession.

Chopping Block - Hits & Misses

Hits

• Demi Moore totally owns her role as Elisabeth, showcasing her vulnerability and descent into madness in a way that hits hard. I was especially struck by the scene where she first sees Sue after using "The Substance"—it’s a real gut punch. Margaret Qualley nails it as Sue, capturing that seductive yet sinister vibe that Elisabeth can’t escape. And let’s talk about Dennis Quaid as Harvey; he adds a wicked layer of dark humor that really drives home the predatory nature of the entertainment industry.

• The film’s visual style is a total feast for the eyes! Those vibrant colors and unsettling images really crank up the horror factor. I love how the set design and cinematography create a world that’s both gorgeous and grotesque, perfectly reflecting the dual lives of Elisabeth and Sue. And let’s talk about the numerous nods to other horror films—those were an unexpected but welcome addition! The sound design? Those eerie silences mixed with jarring noises build tension like crazy, making every scene feel charged with impending doom.

• "The Substance" is a standout in its satirical critique of the beauty industry. I love how the film uses horror to expose the hypocrisy of a society fixated on youth and physical perfection. This sharp satire doesn’t just deliver scares; it makes a bold statement about the insane lengths people will go to in pursuit of an unattainable beauty ideal.

Misses

• I found the narrative to be a bit disjointed at times. With all the nods to classic horror films and the exploration of deeper themes, it sometimes loses focus, which left me with unanswered questions and a feeling of thematic incoherence.

• At 140 minutes, the film’s length is definitely a point of contention. While I appreciate the slow build-up that adds to the tension, some scenes feel unnecessarily prolonged, which can take away from the overall impact. I think the pacing might test the patience of viewers who are looking for a more direct narrative.

• The film’s climax is a visual feast, but I have to say, it veers into overly dramatic and even somewhat humorous territory instead of delivering terror. This tonal shift at the end left me feeling a bit out of sync with the horror that had come before, as the exaggerated conclusion kind of undermines the tension that was so carefully crafted.

  
  

Full Review

• Scare Factor — Points: .5

  "The Substance" really knows how to use body horror to highlight the darker side of beauty and perfection! I was captivated by the unsettling imagery and disturbing transformations that create a sense of dread, making it a compelling watch for anyone who loves the genre.

• Storyline and Plot — Points: .5

  The plot dives into a provocative narrative about identity and self-destruction. But honestly, the film’s ambition sometimes leads to inconsistencies, making some themes feel underexplored or muddled by the complex structure.

• Atmosphere and Setting — Points: 1

  The film’s setting, with its vibrant yet grotesque aesthetic, really plays a crucial role in showcasing the duality of Elisabeth and Sue’s existence. I loved how the meticulous production design and sound work together to create a world that feels both alluring and horrifying.

• Special Effects and Makeup — Points: 1

  I think the practical effects and makeup in this film are standout features, particularly in how they depict Elisabeth’s physical decay. They’re both visceral and symbolic, adding depth to the film's commentary on the destructive nature of the pursuit of beauty.

• Acting and Performances — Points: 1

  Demi Moore absolutely dominates with a powerful performance, and I was equally impressed by Margaret Qualley’s portrayal of Sue. The dynamic between these two characters is key to the film’s narrative, providing a strong emotional core that elevates the horror to another level.

Final Verdict

"The Substance" is a feast for the eyes and a biting critique of our obsession with looks. While it stumbles a bit with some plot points and wraps up in a way that might leave you scratching your head, Demi Moore shines in her role, and the film’s sharp humor keeps things entertaining. Coralie Fargeat’s direction makes it a memorable addition to the horror genre. So grab your popcorn and prepare to question your skincare routine—this film is anything but superficial!

Rating: 4/5

What did you think of "The Substance"?

Head over to Threads, Instagram or Facebook to join in on the conversation. Check out our website for more horror reviews, and for the latest horror news.