The Watchers (2024)

Rating: 1.5/5

Plot Summary

"The Watchers" (2024), directed by Ishana Night Shyamalan, plunges us into the eerie forests of western Ireland. Mina, a 28-year-old artist, and three strangers find themselves ensnared in this nightmarish landscape. As darkness falls, creepy creatures emerge to play their sinister games. Fans of "The Descent" and "The Blair Witch Project" will appreciate the claustrophobic tension and psychological scares. But does "The Watchers" deliver the terror we crave? Let's dive in and find out.

Chopping Block - Hits & Misses

Hits

• Atmospheric Setting: The forest acts as more than just a spooky backdrop; it’s a character in its own right, exuding claustrophobic and eerie vibes that heighten the tension, particularly at night.
  

• Thematic Depth: The film’s dive into voyeurism and identity was a pleasant surprise, adding some much-needed layers to the narrative. It had the potential to elevate the movie beyond your typical creature feature.

• Performances: Georgina Campbell totally nails it. Even when the script falters, her performance shines through, giving the movie an emotional anchor that’s hard to ignore.

Misses

• Script and Dialogue: Yikes. The clumsy script and vapid dialogue drag down the film’s potential, with heavy-handed exposition robbing it of an immersive horror experience.

• Character Development: Dakota Fanning’s portrayal of Mina lacks depth, making it hard to connect with her character.

• Creature Design and Execution: Those forest creatures start off so promising! But then – wham! – they show us way too much way too soon. They’re creepiest when lurking in the shadows, but overexposure robs them of their scare factor.

Full Review

• Scare Factor — Points: .5 "The Watchers" knows how to keep you on the edge of your seat, especially during those spooky nighttime scenes. The suspense builds up beautifully but, fair warning, once the creatures are fully revealed, the fear factor takes a nosedive.

• Storyline and Plot — Points: 0 The film attempts to explore voyeurism and identity, but the clumsy script and dull dialogue undermine it, making it feel a bit bloated and aimless.

• Atmosphere and Setting — Points: .5 The nighttime silhouettes and partial reveals? Suspense heaven. But they shot themselves in the foot by revealing the creatures way too early.

• Special Effects and Makeup — Points: 0 The initial design of the forest creatures is spot-on, but the special effects falter once they’re fully exposed. Overexposure strips them of their mystery and menace.

• Acting and Performances — Points: .5 Despite the script’s hiccups, the main cast really steps up. Georgina Campbell, in particular, steals the show with her compelling presence. Dakota Fanning’s Mina? Stoic, sure, but she doesn’t quite hit the mark when it comes to making us feel those desperate moments.

Final Verdict

"The Watchers" (2024) aims high but lands among the clouds. Ishana Night Shyamalan shows promise as a director, but her debut suffers from an unfocused script that doesn’t live up to its intriguing premise. The film offers genuine tension and a wonderfully eerie atmosphere but struggles to piece together a coherent and engaging story. Horror fans might appreciate its ambitious themes and creepy setting, but it’s more of an interesting misfire than a home run. Sometimes what lurks in the shadows is terrifying—until you flip on the lights and realize it’s just a coat on a chair.

Rating: 1.5/5

What did you think of "The Watchers"?

Head over to Threads, Instagram or Facebook to join in on the conversation. Check out our website for more horror reviews, and for the latest horror news.